- Display 24 Products per page
-
CARR VALLEY, CHEESE CURDS
A local Wisconsin favorite made fresh in our vats everyday. Squeaky fresh cheddar curds to be eaten within 2 to 5 days.
-
CARR VALLEY, MOBAY
Sid`s whimsically delicious take on the famous French cheese, Morbier. Our version features a layer of sheep milk cheese and a layer of goat milk cheese separated by a layer of grape vine ash and pressed together. The flavor is both delicate and rustic. Taste each layer separately and then together for three different flavor profiles in one great cheese. Serve with a Chenin Blanc or a Riesling.
-
CARR VALLEY PENTA CREME
Made from cow’s milk with the addition of a substantial amount of cream, Penta Crème Blue is one of a handful of new cheeses being produced by Carr Valley at their new blue cheese factory, Glacier Point. The texture of Penta Crème is very smooth and cream-like, much like a double cream cheese. Flavors are earthy and rich, with distinctive lactic notes.
-
CARR VALLEY, SMOKED FONTINA
A soft white cheese, lightly smoked, with great meltability and flexability. Great on pizza, fondue, soup or to eat.
-
DEER CREEK, 7 YR PROPRIETOR`S CHEDDAR
1st PLACE MATURE CHEDDARS – AMERICAN CHEESE SOCIETY AWARDS 2023
Deer Creek 7 Year Proprietor’s Grand Reserve is produced by Land O’ Lakes in the Niagra Cuesta region of Eastern Wisconsin. This cheese, which has aged for a full 7 years, is carefully selected for its quality by cheese grading experts. It is selected for its balance of distinctive bold flavors, which give way to a rich, lingering finish, and its balance of a firm and smooth texture that does not become dry and crumbly.
-
DEER CREEK, BLUE JAY
3rd PLACE OPEN CATEGORY FLAVOR ADDED – AMERICAN CHEESE SOCIETY AWARDS 2023
Made using a Quintuple Cream Blue recipe, The Blue Jay is rich in texture with strong buttery notes. We then crush juniper berries to release their perfume and infuse them throughout to compliment the Blue strains unique botanical essence. The result is a bold, yet utterly creamy Blue with a delicately piney bouquet that unfolds in your mouth. While The Blue Jay is wonderful with any of our suggested pairings, try it melted on a New York Strip for a truly decadent meal.
-
DEER CREEK, THE FAWN CHEDDAR
This traditional 22 lb. daisy wheel Cheddar is completely handcrafted from wholesome rBST-free milk from Wisconsin. A unique culture set gives this young cheese an award-winning, sweet nuttiness with a full, complex Cheddar flavor not found in traditional bandage-wrapped Cheddars. As the flavor of The Fawn unfolds in your mouth, it seems delicate at first, yet gives a richness in finish that lingers on.
2023 Awards
Gold for Best USA Cheese, Cheddar: Mild — International Cheese Awards
2nd Place for Traditional Waxed Cheddar, Sharp to Aged — US Championship Cheese Contest
2nd Place — Wisconsin State Fair Dairy Products Competition
-
DEER CREEK MOON RABBIT
Deer Creek’s The MoonRabbit is proof that the moon is truly made of green cheese. Cured, sweet finish Cheddar, bathed it in Green Chartreuse liqueur. The Chartreuse adds a delicate herbal bouquet with hints of cloves, citrus, rosemary, and thyme that beautifully complements the cheese’s creaminess while imparting a light green hue.
-
DEER CREEK, RATTLESNAKE CHEDDAR
The Rattlesnake is a true flavor experience spicy, sweet, tropical, and HOT. We start with a smooth, creamy medium aged Cheddar and infuse it with premium gold tequila and Habanero peppers. The warmth and sweetness of the tequila opens your palate to the smooth and creamy mellowness of a perfect aged Cheddar. And just when you are wondering where the Habaneros are, the heat bursts forth for an unforgettable finish. Watch out this cheese just might bite you back!
-
DEER CREEK, THE STAG CHEDDAR
Select vats of The Fawn are chosen for further aging to allow for the development of the intense, bold flavor characteristics of The Stag. It is rugged, driving strong toffee and butterscotch notes, yet possesses the sweet finish of The Fawn. As it ages, The Stag develops a hint of crystalline crunch to further enliven the taste buds with rich texture as well as flavor. The Stag, a true Wisconsin Original, is a traditional bandage-wrapped 22 lb. daisy wheel Cheddar. Chosen as one of the “101 Best Cheeses of the Year†by Culture Magazine.
-
DEER CREEK, VAT 17 CHEDDAR
The creation of this unique cheese began as a quest to capture the best flavor attributes from Cheddars around the world and blend them into one unique cheese. Vat 17 is bold and complex, with a tangy nuttiness that is unsurpassed. It is a highly decorated cheese, winning numerous awards the world over.
-
KONTOS, IMPORTED GREEK FETA, PAIL
The distinctive, tangy taste of our Feta is delicious crumbled over traditional Mediterranean salads or served on an appetizer tray with our olives and flatbread.
-
FOUR FAT FOWL, ST. STEPHEN
Our first cheese is a beautiful, hand-crafted triple cream that bursts with buttery and milky overtones. A smooth, silky interior made from all natural jersey cow’s milk and fresh jersey cream creates the perfect texture, while our soft, bloomy rind adds an earthy flavor with nutty undertones. St. Stephen will leave you wanting more to share with a friend and a glass of bubbly. This classic cheese works anytime of day – spread it on your toast for breakfast, serve it as an appetizer before dinner or dress it up with some honey or berries for a fancy dessert.
-
FETA, BULGARIAN, SHEEP
The history of Feta cheese, though often under debate, has been traced to the Balkan Peninsula in modern-day Bulgaria. Bulgarian Feta is made from pure sheep’s milk from ewes that graze in the Rhodope Mountains and features a stark white color and slightly salty flavor with a refreshing, tangy finish. Stemming from the Italian word for slice, or “fetta,” this feta cheese is formed into blocks and sliced, making it perfect for a drizzle of olive oil, or crumbed into your favorite dishes.
-
CREAM CHEESE, DOMESTIC
It is a modern, fresh cheese made of cow`s milk. It is an acid curd cheese, but unlike cottage cheese, it requires a starter culture of bacteria. It is generally mild and velvety. Sometimes whey powder is added which results in more grainy texture of cheese. Perfect for cheesecakes and baking.
-
CARR VALLEY, GLACIER GORGONZOLA
Back room Trattoria delicious! Imbued with melodious mushroom truffle notes. A symphony of pure flavor! Great for salads, pastas and snacking!
-
GENEVA, GOAT CHEESE LOGS
Fresh goat cheese logs, hand crafted from fresh prime quality milk. Vacuum packed to lock freshness and extend shelf life.
Shelf Life: 120 Days Keep refrigerated 34-36 °F -
CELEBRITY, GOAT CHEESE WITH HONEY
With honey at the helm, a hint of sweet is the ideal accompaniment to the velvety taste of Celebrity goat cheese. This young, fresh cheese is creamy enough to spread but firm enough to slice, resulting in a mild, smooth and refreshing goat’s milk cheese. The touch of honey creates a mellow tone to the cheese, while its pale ivory color gives a hint to the drop of “liquid gold” inherent in this delightful twist on an already delicious cheese.
-
GENEVA, GOAT CHEESE PAIL
Fresh goat cheese made from fresh prime quality milk and packed in bulk. Montchevre fresh goat cheese has a soft and smooth texture. It has a mild-tangy flavor and is an ideal ingredient as a base for sauce, ravioli filling, melted on pizza or crumbled on a salad.
Shelf Life: 120 Days Keep refrigerated 34-36°F -
HOOK`S, THREE YEAR CHEDDAR
Hook’s Cheese ages cheddar from 1-15 years. Our cheese is made 1 batch at a time, curds transferred to forms by hand, and aged to perfection. Our cheddar is known for its smooth, creamy texture and for the amazing flavors that develop every year it is aged, from smooth and mellow to sharp and crumbly. Every age has its own unique flavor and texture.
-
HOOK`S, FIVE YEAR CHEDDA
Hook’s Cheese ages cheddar from 1-15 years. Our cheese is made 1 batch at a time, curds transferred to forms by hand, and aged to perfection. Our cheddar is known for its smooth, creamy texture and for the amazing flavors that develop every year it is aged, from smooth and mellow to sharp and crumbly. Every age has its own unique flavor and texture.
-
HOOK`S, TEN YEAR CHEDDAR
Hook’s Cheese ages cheddar from 1-15 years. Our cheese is made 1 batch at a time, curds transferred to forms by hand, and aged to perfection. Our cheddar is known for its smooth, creamy texture and for the amazing flavors that develop every year it is aged, from smooth and mellow to sharp and crumbly. Every age has its own unique flavor and texture.
-
HOOK`S, EWE CALF TO BE KIDDING
This amazing mixed milk blue made with sheep, cow, and goat milk is aged 9-12 months resulting in big, complex flavor with a wonderful texture from tyrosine crystals and a rich, creamy finish. It is sublime paired with a chocolaty, coffee flavored Porter beer! This cheese won 1st place at ACS in 2018.
-
HOOK`S, RED ERRIGAL
Named after the mountain in Ireland in honor of Tony’s heritage. Colby style cheese but made with sheep and cow milks-aged over 2 years for added flavor, it makes an amazing grilled cheese!
