- Display 45 Products per page
-
PATRIA, SHREDDED MOZZARELLA, LOW-MOISTURE, WHOLE MILK
Your Patrons come to you for authentic, New York-style pizzas offering big, bold taste experiences. Give them the best with Patria® – the full-flavored mozzarella that shares your extraordinary dedication to quality, consistency and guest satisfaction.
-
NETTLE MEADOW, POTASH MOUNTAIN (GOAT/COW), 6/8 OZ
Potash Mountain
This tangy pyramid made of goat and cows milk compliments any cheese board with its height and unique flavor. The rind is dusted with our iconic vegetable black ash before it ages. The bloomy rind grows on top of the ash, creating a delightful, multi-dimensional layer when cut into.
-
CARR VALLEY, PENTA CREME, RETAIL
A revolutionary five-creme blue, master crafted to be the most decadent blue available from your friends at Carr Valley Cheese.
-
POINT REYES, TOMA PLAIN
In Italian, Toma means “wheel of cheese made by the farmer herself.” What better way to describe this, our most versatile, any time, any table cheese. All natural, pasteurized, semi-hard table cheese with a waxed rind.
- Made from pasteurized, rBST-free cows’ milk
- Made with microbial (vegetarian) rennet
- Aged for 90 days
- Gluten Free
- Wedges are individually vacuum sealed
-
HERKIMER COUNTY, YELLOW CHEDDAR
Normally, the color of Cheddar ranges from white to pale yellow. Some Cheddars, however, have a color added, giving the cheese a yellow-orange color. Cheddar is always made from cow`s milk and has a slightly crumbly texture if properly cured. If the cheese is too young, the texture is smooth. Cheddar gets a sharper taste the longer it matures.
-
ROELLI, DUNBARTON BLUE
A hand crafted, cellar cured cheese with the earthy character of a fine English-style cheddar, coupled with the subtle hint of blue flavor. Open air curing creates a natural, edible rind. Made with pasteurized cow’s milk and aged at least 90 days.
-
NETTLE MEADOW, SUGAR LOAF MINIS
Buttery, decadent and slightly mushroomy as the cheese develops, these small wheels are 100% Jersey cow’s milk triple crème.
-
GENEVA, GOAT CHEESE LOGS
Fresh goat cheese logs, hand crafted from fresh prime quality milk. Vacuum packed to lock freshness and extend shelf life.
Shelf Life: 120 Days Keep refrigerated 34-36 °F -
DEER CREEK, 7 YR PROPRIETOR`S CHEDDAR
1st PLACE MATURE CHEDDARS – AMERICAN CHEESE SOCIETY AWARDS 2023
Deer Creek 7 Year Proprietor’s Grand Reserve is produced by Land O’ Lakes in the Niagra Cuesta region of Eastern Wisconsin. This cheese, which has aged for a full 7 years, is carefully selected for its quality by cheese grading experts. It is selected for its balance of distinctive bold flavors, which give way to a rich, lingering finish, and its balance of a firm and smooth texture that does not become dry and crumbly.
-
MOUCO, ASHLEY
2nd PLACE SOFT RIPENED – AMERICAN CHEESE SOCIETY AWARDS 2023
A lightly stiff center when young, complimented by a buzz of tartness. As the cheese ripens, the pate develops a creamier flavor and texture. A hint of sweetness compliments a bit of hum in the finish. At 7-8 weeks, the cheese is fully ripe, soft and gooey, a definitive line shows off the soft edible rind. A murmur of sweetness balances the complex cheese.
-
LA CLARE,FIG & HONEY CHEVRE
1st PLACE FRESH GOAT W/ SWEET FLAVOR ADDED – AMERICAN CHEESE SOCIETY AWARDS 2023
Sweet figs and honey are combined with our Original Goat Cheese for a balance of sweet and rich flavors.
-
LIUZZI , CACIOCAVALLO
3rd PLACE PASTA FILATA – AMERICAN CHEESE SOCIETY AWARDS 2023
Caciocavallo, which means cheese on horseback, gets its name from the manner in which the cheese is always tied together in a rope and dangled over a wooden board to drain and age. An Italian type of pasta filata cheese made out of sheep`s or cow`s milk, it is produced throughout Southern Italy and the Balkans.
Continuous exposure to humidity in the caves and aging develops sharp, spicy flavors in Caciocavallo. With persistent aging, the cheese picks up intense, earthy undertones and fruity aromas. Along the way, it turns from a milky white to a darker yellow in color and becomes more salty. The result is a cheese with profound tasting notes and perfect accompaniment to a glass of red wine.
Made from cow’s milk
Country of origin: Italy
Region: Southern Italy
Type: soft
Texture: springy and stringy
Rind: natural
Color: yellow -
DEER CREEK, BLUE JAY
3rd PLACE OPEN CATEGORY FLAVOR ADDED – AMERICAN CHEESE SOCIETY AWARDS 2023
Made using a Quintuple Cream Blue recipe, The Blue Jay is rich in texture with strong buttery notes. We then crush juniper berries to release their perfume and infuse them throughout to compliment the Blue strains unique botanical essence. The result is a bold, yet utterly creamy Blue with a delicately piney bouquet that unfolds in your mouth. While The Blue Jay is wonderful with any of our suggested pairings, try it melted on a New York Strip for a truly decadent meal.
-
BEEHIVE, TEAHIVE
Teahive is a “feel good” cheese. The soothing qualities of tea and the relaxing properties of bergamot combine to produce a lovely cheese with rich fragrances of orange blossoms in April.What does it taste like?Sweet and creamy, this Jersey cow’s milk cheese immediately delights the palate and the complexities of the tea-rubbed rind continue through the finish.
-
LIUZZI, STRACCIATELLA, FROZEN, 5 LB.
Homemade! We hand-pull strands of fresh mozzarella and add our own cultured cream to create this amazing textural stracciatella.
-
LA CLARE, AGED GOAT CHEDDAR
This pressed curd cheese is made from whole pasteurized goat milk and is aged for over 6 months.
It is a complex cheese with nutty notes and a creamy texture.
-
CARR VALLEY, CRANBERRY CHIPOTLE CHEDDAR STIX
Your favorite Carr Valley Cheese, now in snacking form!
Carr Valley Cheese Stix are the smart snack anyone can enjoy anytime, anywhere. Never has an artisan cheese been packaged in an easier to consume fashion that’s perfect to toss in a backpack or briefcase.
These handcrafted artisan cheese snacks go equally well with a nice glass of Pinot as they do in your kid’s lunchbox. As always, our Stix are made from milk produced without hormones, antibiotics, or GMOs. Grab, go and enjoy.
-
LA CLARE, CHEVRE LOGS
This Goat Cheese’s (chèvre) clean flavor starts with goat milk that makes a short trip from the farms to the creamery, guaranteeing a clean and fresh taste. This cheese has a milky, delicate, mild flavor complemented by hints of tangy sweetness.
-
DEER CREEK, IMPERIAL BUCK
Like the award-winning Fawn and Stag, Deer Creek’s The Imperial Buck is a handmade, bandaged-wrapped cheddar. It is carefully aged for a longer period of time to allow for an even greater development of its rich nutty flavor and sweet butterscotch finish. The unique nuttiness is pronounced, yet blends beautifully with the buttery sweetness of the Cheddar. The crystalline crunch offers a nice contrast to the cheese’s creamy texture. The unique beauty of this cheese is the perfect harmony of nut, cream, butter, and sweet flavors to complement and balance each other. It is truly a one-of-a-kind, outstanding best-in-class cheddar.
-
DEER CREEK, RATTLESNAKE CHEDDAR
The Rattlesnake is a true flavor experience spicy, sweet, tropical, and HOT. We start with a smooth, creamy medium aged Cheddar and infuse it with premium gold tequila and Habanero peppers. The warmth and sweetness of the tequila opens your palate to the smooth and creamy mellowness of a perfect aged Cheddar. And just when you are wondering where the Habaneros are, the heat bursts forth for an unforgettable finish. Watch out this cheese just might bite you back!
-
BEEHIVE, BARELY BUZZED
1st PLACE RUBBED RIND CHEESE – AMERICAN CHEESE SOCIETY AWARDS 2023
This is a full bodied cheese with a nutty flavor and smooth texture. The cheese is hand rubbed with a Turkish grind of Colorado Legacy Coffee Company`s (The Cheesemakers brother) `Beehive Blend`. The blend consists of a mix of South American, Central American, and Indonesian beans roasted to different styles. French Superior Lavender buds are ground with the coffee and the mixture is diluted with oil to suspend the dry ingredients in the rub. The rub imparts notes of butterscotch and caramel which are prevalent near the rind, but find their way to the center of the cheese. The cheese is aged on Utah Blue Spruce aging racks in our humidity controlled caves, and moved to different temperature during the aging process to develop texture and flavor. The name `Barely Buzzed` comes from Andrea at Deluxe Foods in California. She was the winner of the name this cheese contest. Awards – 1st Place, American Cheese Society Annual Competition 2007, 2008, 2009 and 2011.
-
HOOK`S, THREE YEAR CHEDDAR
Hook’s Cheese ages cheddar from 1-15 years. Our cheese is made 1 batch at a time, curds transferred to forms by hand, and aged to perfection. Our cheddar is known for its smooth, creamy texture and for the amazing flavors that develop every year it is aged, from smooth and mellow to sharp and crumbly. Every age has its own unique flavor and texture.
-
FOUR FAT FOWL, ST. STEPHEN
Our first cheese is a beautiful, hand-crafted triple cream that bursts with buttery and milky overtones. A smooth, silky interior made from all natural jersey cow’s milk and fresh jersey cream creates the perfect texture, while our soft, bloomy rind adds an earthy flavor with nutty undertones. St. Stephen will leave you wanting more to share with a friend and a glass of bubbly. This classic cheese works anytime of day – spread it on your toast for breakfast, serve it as an appetizer before dinner or dress it up with some honey or berries for a fancy dessert.
-
BEEMSTER, CLASSIC NATURAL SMOKED GOUDA, RETAIL
Our young Beemster is naturally slow-smoked over hickory wood in the USA to create this exceptional take on smoked Gouda. It’s mild and creamy, with a soft texture and toasty smokiness reminiscent of campfires and caramelized marshmallows.
-
SAXON CREAMERY, BIG ED’S GOUDA
Award Winning Big Eds Gouda is Saxon Creamery’s flagship cheese. Handcrafted with all the cream left in our rich quality RBHT free milk from a 6th Generation Dairy Farm in Wisconsin. Semi-soft Gouda that is buttery, smooth, creamy.
-
MARIEKE GOUDA, TRUFFLE
Decadently rich Gouda with savory aromas. This farmstead cheese has woody flavor notes brimming at the surface. All Marieke® Gouda is made using fresh raw milk from our family farm. We handcraft each wheel with the finest Old World techniques and age the Gouda to perfection on Dutch Pine Planks.
-
DEER CREEK, THE FAWN CHEDDAR
This traditional 22 lb. daisy wheel Cheddar is completely handcrafted from wholesome rBST-free milk from Wisconsin. A unique culture set gives this young cheese an award-winning, sweet nuttiness with a full, complex Cheddar flavor not found in traditional bandage-wrapped Cheddars. As the flavor of The Fawn unfolds in your mouth, it seems delicate at first, yet gives a richness in finish that lingers on.
2023 Awards
Gold for Best USA Cheese, Cheddar: Mild — International Cheese Awards
2nd Place for Traditional Waxed Cheddar, Sharp to Aged — US Championship Cheese Contest
2nd Place — Wisconsin State Fair Dairy Products Competition
-
STELLA, MEDIUM ASIAGO
A six-month aging period produces a mild, crumbly texture for the Stella Medium Asiago Cheese. This Asiago Cheese has a toasted, sweet and buttery flavor, and the color has aged to a pale beige.
-
LIVELY RUN, FINGER LAKES GOLD
Finger Lakes Gold is a goat’s milk cheese, aged for at least three months. It is mellow and nutty in flavor and firm in texture, with a beautiful natural rind.
Finger Lakes Gold is delicious with egg-based dishes and melts very well. It is also a wonderfully unique addition to any cheese board, pairing well with cured meats as well as jams or fruit.
Finger Lakes Gold won a Silver Medal in its class at the ACS competition in 2023.
-
LA CLARE, EVERYTHING CHEVRE
Our Everything Bagel seasoning is mixed with our Original Goat Cheese to produce a savory and tangy flavor.
-
CYPRESS GROVE, HUMBOLT FOG
3rd PLACE OPEN CATEGORY GOAT’S MILK – AMERICAN CHEESE SOCIETY AWARDS 2023
Our signature offering, Humboldt Fog is an elegant, soft, surface ripened cheese. The texture is creamy and luscious with a subtle tangy flavor. Each handcrafted wheel features a ribbon of edible vegetable ash along its center and a coating of ash under its exterior to give it a distinctive, cake-like appearance. An American Original!
-
DEER CREEK, WILD BOAR
Earthy black truffle ambles between creamy Monterey Jack curds to craft the decadent yet approachable sensory experience that is The Wild Boar. Each bite transports your palate to the Wisconsin North with the savory truffles’ warm and woodsy notes coupled with mild, buttery cheese. This charming and aromatic Jack easily finds its home on a board or melted into dishes for a delightfully mushroomy finish.
-
BEEHIVE, SMOKED APPLE SMOKED W/APPLE & WALNUT, 8/5 LB
This creamy Utah cheddar is lightly smoked with walnut wood and wedges of sliced apple. In 2019 the American Cheese Society declared Apple Walnut Smoked to be the best Smoked Cheddar in AmericaWhat does it taste like? Sweet and creamy, Apple Walnut Smoked has the perfect amount of smoke. This artful balance allows both the cheese and its smoky character to shine.
-
MOUCO, CHEESE CURDS
MouCo Cheddar Cheese curds are small, solid pieces of fresh cheese. They are white in color, and have a firm, springy texture. Cheese curds are often eaten on their own as a snack, or used in a variety of dishes, such as poutine, cheese soup, and grilled cheese sandwiches.
MouCo Cheese curds are made from milk that has been curdled with rennet. The curds are then cut into small pieces and salted.
Cheese curds are a popular snack in the Midwestern United States and Canada. They are also a popular ingredient in poutine, a Canadian dish of french fries, cheese curds, and gravy. Cheese curds can also be used in a variety of other dishes, such as cheese soup, grilled cheese sandwiches, and mac and cheese.
These squeaky cheese snacks are a great way to add a little bit of indulgence to your day.
-
DEER CREEK, THE FAWN, RETAIL
This traditional 22 lb. daisy wheel Cheddar is completely handcrafted from wholesome rBST-free milk from Wisconsin. A unique culture set gives this young cheese an award-winning sweet nuttiness with a full, complex Cheddar flavor not found in traditional bandage-wrapped Cheddars. As the flavor of The Fawn unfolds in your mouth, it seems delicate at first, yet gives you a rich finish that lingers on.
-
STELLA, ASIAGO AGED
The extra-long aging of the 12-month Stella Aged Asiago Cheese renders a robust, sharp cheese with a complex, nutty flavor and mature yellow color. The texture is firm and crumbly.
-
BEEHIVE, RED BUTTE (HATCH GREEN CHILI), 2/5 LB
Winner of 4 Major Awards This cheese is an expression of love for the landscape of the American Southwest; the rind is almost as stunning as a Canyonlands vista. Beautifully layered like Entrada Sandstone, the paste of Red Butte is tumbled with Hatch Chiles and complex flavors. What does it taste like? Creamy and smoky with a proper balance of heat. The coriander in the rub on the rind gives Red Butte a mellow lemony undertone.
-
TILLAMOOK, MEDIUM YELLOW CHEDDAR LOAF
At Tillamook, we remain guided by the same values and beliefs we started with in 1909. We believe quality comes above profit and that natural always beats artificial. We never cut corners—it’s just not our style. We source the highest quality ingredients to bring you products that are DOWNRIGHT DELICIOUS. We promise to do things the right way, always, because the only thing we love more than making our food, is making it for you.
-
JACK, MONTEREY
Young Jack cheeses are delicate, mild and fresh. This fresh version is creamy and elastic.
-
BEEHIVE, POUR ME A SLICE, 10/4 OZ RETAIL
Beehive Cheese Company’s “Utah Cheddar” with a side of booze! Pour Me a Slice is imbued with Basil Hayden’s Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey.
-
HOOK`S, RED ERRIGAL
Named after the mountain in Ireland in honor of Tony’s heritage. Colby style cheese but made with sheep and cow milks-aged over 2 years for added flavor, it makes an amazing grilled cheese!
-
LIVELY RUN, BLUE YONDER, 1/4#
Our Blue Yonder is a creamy cow’s milk blue cheese with natural rind that is both subtle, complex and approachable. While the rich Holstein milk gives the paste a lovely yellow color, it is marbled throughout with pockets and veins of deep blue.